Story archive - Hook water supply articles
published 8:17am Saturday Nov 1, 2008
The dream of providing a 50-year water supply has been controversial this year, as Hook water articles demonstrate.
This page also includes links to official and other documents linked by these stories.
• February 28, 2008 - COVER- Reservoir dogged: A $142 million boondoggle?
2005 report - Gannett Fleming: Ragged Mountain Reservoir Expansion [PDF]
2008 maps - Hook: the urban water system and reservoir proximity to airport [html]
• March 6, 2008 - NEWS- Higher and higher: Frederick claimed dredge cost $225 million
2005 minutes - RWSA - regulator meeting between local officials and regulators [PDF]
• March 13, 2008 - PHOTOPHILE- Wild waters: new dam would inundate hidden park
• March 13, 2008 - COVER-Trickling away: A dam develops amid missed chances
2005 letter - 17 environmental leaders: blasting state dam deadline as ‘artificial’ [DOC]
2004 resolution - Sally Thomas: blasts RWSA, supports water supply dredging [html]
2004 study - Gannett Fleming: “Safe Yield Study” measures system at 16 MGD [PDF]
2004 study - Gannett Fleming: “Demand Analysis” predicts doubling of usage [PDF]
2008 report - UVA: aggressive conservation measures cut water use over time [html]
2004 minutes - Gannett Fleming says dredging will supply 5.5 MGD [PDF]
2004 report - Gannett Fleming: dredging costs up to $145 million [PDF]
2007 report - Gannett Fleming: dredging costs up to $223 million [PDF]
• March 13, 2008 - Surprise! Dredge meets 115% of 50-year demand (online only)
2005 report - Gannett Fleming: contends urban system only supplies 12.8 MGD [html]
• March 20, 2008 - NEWS- Case studies: Will new dredge view go entrepreneurial?
2009 budget - RWSA reveals it wants to borrow $105 million [PDF]
• March 27, 2008 - NEWS- ‘Full steam ahead’: Emails suggest O’Connell, Conservancy blocking dredging
• April 3, 2008 - The water plan ad appears here too (online only)
2008 ad - RWSA claims wide support for water plan [PDF]
• April 3, 2008 - NEWS- ‘Conservative’ tale: When a single Mud Cat just won’t do
2004 memo - RWSA: Frederick dodges no-confidence vote [PDF]
2008 email - Airport Director: blasts dredging supporter, cites Conservancy official [RTF]
2008 letter - Nature Conservancy official recharacterizes role [PDF]
• April 17, 2008 - NEWS- Revealing docs: Dredging foes run up the tab
2001 report - VHB: engineers summarize gamut of existing local water knowledge [PDF]
2002 report - RWSA director Tropea enthuses about post-drought plan [powerpoint]
2002 memo - RWSA: finalizes dredge-friendly water supply plan in wake of drought [RTF]
2002 contract - RWSA: original water supply plan Gannett Fleming hired to implement for 798K [PDF]
2003 memo - Gannett Fleming: unveils new dam idea as better than dredging [PDF]
2004 memo - Gannett Fleming: slams prior data, dredging too expensive at $42 million [PDF]
2004 memo - Gannett Fleming: rewrites its mission or “Scope of Services” [PDF]
2005 memo - Gannett Fleming: downplays dredging despite airport & contractor interest [PDF]
• April 24, 2008 - NEWS- Sierra missed: Club urges dredging, O’Connell soldiers on
2008 letter - Sierra Club: urges water supply dredging [RTF]
2008 email - City manager: urges RWSA director to keep a new presentation under wraps [PDF]
• May 1, 2008 - NEWS- Open tap: Dam firm continues to drain city coffers
2008 memo - William Crutchfield: electronics magnate urges more businesslike approach [RTF]
2008 letter - Sally Thomas: County Supervisors replies to Sierra Club, defends plan [RTF]
2008 presentation - Gannett Fleming: draft presentation of $12K anti-dredging report: [PDF]
• May 1, 2008 - Rooker rains on Frederick’s parade (online only)
• May 5, 2008 - Dredging confabs: 7pm tonight & 5pm tomorrow (online only)
• May 7, 2008 - Keno, Lynch dredge up divergent views (online only)
2008 notice - A.C.S.A. proposes 20% spike in water rates [PDF]
• May 8, 2008 - NEWS- Dredging 101: New estimate at $25-30 million
• May 8, 2008 - County water rates to spike 20% (online only)
2008 budget - A.C.S.A. slates $7 million in pipe-replacement and other capital projects [spreadsheet]
2009 budget - RWSA: raises water rate to County for water by 2.44, sewer 10.54 percent [PDF]
2008 doc - A.C.S.A.: shows rates rising 1998-2007 [PDF}
• May 11, 2008 - P.E.C. opens new fronts in war on dredging (online only)
• May 14, 2008 - Crutchfield: I'm no dredging expert (online only)
• May 15, 2008 - NEWS- Money pit: Quarry offered as dredging base
• May 22, 2008 - NEWS- Competing visions: Citizens unveil alternate 50-year plan
2002 flyer - Citzens group: offers $81-125 million counter-proposal [PDF].
• May 29, 2008 - NEWS-Empty file? State has no record of water plan
state regulation - Virginia: Title 9 lists the things RWSA has not yet done [PDF]
2008 flyer - RWSA: dubiously claims that DEQ rejected the dredging option [PDF]
2008 report - RWSA: 51-pages of “mitigation” for Ragged Mountain dam/pipeline damage [PDF]
2008 report - RWSA: $7.7 million reforestation, stream mitigation budget [JPG]
2008 report - RWSA: 93-page regulatory “Permit Support Document” [PDF]
2008 letter - Dam/pipeline supporter Dr. Elizabeth Palmer: a “personal perspective” [PDF]”
• June 1, 2008 - Hamilton: reject ‘pig in a poke’ water scheme (online only)
2008 letter- Kendra Hamilton: Former Councilor cites cost and fairness issues [RTF]
2008 resolution - Gary O’Connell: still supporting official plan despite Council prod [RTF]
• June 5, 2008 - Schilling blasts water project, O’Connell’s ‘fiefdom’
• June 5, 2008 - NEWS- Hamilton ‘pokes’: Council issues demand for dredging
• June 12, 2008 - Duped councilors? Three now slam O’Connell’s water leadership
• June 12, 2008 - Albemarle to water authority: Study dredging
• June 15, 2008 - Dredge fans take it to the streets
• June 23, 2008 - Waterworks seeks scopeless dredge proposals
• June 28, 2008 - Dredge this! (online only)
• July 3, 2008 - Overrun O’Connell? Does the City Manager spend too much?
• July 28, 2008 - Frederick: RWSA agrees to delay dredge study
• August 4, 2008 - Stacked deck? Dredge foes outnumber fans on force
• August 7, 2008 - CHO work confounds, excites dredge fans
• September 2, 2008 - Water leak: Another group jumps ship?
• September 22, 2008 - Water surprise: Reservoir halted after price doubles
• September 29, 2008 - Pipe dream: Mega-reservoir tied to moribund Bypass
• October 1, 2008 - Creepy glue: Dam firm settles in death, dodges questions
• October 7, 2008 - Crutchfield Ink: Tycoon urges halt on ‘bridge to nowhere’
2008 letter - William Crutchfield: RWSA should halt this ‘bridge to nowhere’ [DOC]
• October 27, 2008 - Water Authority not ready for pipeline talk
• November 3, 2008 - Neighborhoods press Council on dredging
• November 6, 2008 - Gary, oh! O’Connell finally agrees to halt dam
2008 Resolution - City Council: demands RWSA halt dam/pipeline bottom [DOC, PDF]
2008 email - O’Connell: expresses ignorance that existing dam can be fixed [PDF]
2008 Resolution - City Council: demands dredging & conservation June 2 [DOC, PDF]
• November 10, 2008 - Hide and leak? Dam costs at least $20 million more
2008 press release - RWSA: claims new dam cost “approximately $70 million” [PDF]
2008 cost breakdown - RWSA claims in January dam costs $37 million a [PDF]
• November 14, 2008 - Soil & Water board joins City seeking dam halt
• November 24, 2008 - Pumped up: County water guru says numbers inflated
2008 memo - Water Resources Manager Greg Harper: alleges demand has been inflated on [pdf]
2008 email - Incredulous RWSA board member Gary O’Connell asking about Harper [pdf]
2008 chart - UVA shows vastly reduced water consumption over decade [html]
2008 chart - RWSA figures: show total local consumption falling over decade [pdf]
• December 1, 2008 - Water panic: in giant confab, officials agree to study pipeline
• December 6, 2008 - Gauntlet thrown? County rejects alternate water sources
• December 8, 2008 - Gaffney undrained: Confident water boss seeks fourth term
• December 15, 2008 - Gaffney retained: City parts waters for RWSA helmsman
• January 2, 2009 - Green kit: Is a $1.2 million reservoir in the bag?
• January 13, 2009 - Bicentennial blah: Nothing locally for Poe’s 200th… yet
• January 26, 2009 - Water park? Dredge force stresses rowing, not dredging
• February 23, 2009 - Prescribed logic: Water/sewer rates set for 11-12% hike/
• March 2, 2009 - Use dwindles: But water debt may more than triple
• March 3, 2009 - Dredge the res? City Councilors say it’s about time
• March 19, 2009 - County to sell less water, hike rates 12%+/
• May 7, 2009 - Obama quip: Dredging stalls as racial debate rises
• May 14, 2009 - Unblocked reservoir? RWSA may okay dredging study
• May 14, 2009 - Dollar short: Dredging study advances… on City tab
• June 18, 2009 - 4X club: Rewarding thrift, County hits water hogs
• June 19, 2009 - Eight firms want to show us how to dredge
• June 25, 2009 - More spending: Rivanna moves past Gannett Fleming
• July 27, 2009 - Down 22%: Water thrift backfires on RWSA
• August 7, 2009 - Can kicked? Waste decried as dredge study firm named
• August 14, 2009 - Snow softens: Only Fenwick is jonesin’ for dredging
• August 25, 2009 - Dredge wedge: Firm late, wants nearly $700K
• September 4, 2009 - Fish jump: But red herrings filleted at dredge test
• September 21, 2009 - Hard path: Waterworks to approve new firm, new spending
2009 Hook chart - Rivanna may reach $12 million w/o adding capacity [pdf]
• October 2, 2009 - Free studies: Firm, Fenwick urge market dredgings
• November 3, 2009 - Slutzky ousted; Machine coasts to victory in City
• November 7, 2009 - Supe-elect Thomas eyes water plan for ax
Download files »
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0709/cover-reservoir-doc-RaggedMountainStudyFeb2005.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0709/cover-reservoir-doc-MinutesofRegulatorsApril2005.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0711/cover-water-doc-artificialCrisisLetter2005.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0711/cover-water-doc-SafeYieldStudy.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0711/cover-water-doc-demandanalysis.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0711/cover-water-doc-RWSAminutes-nov18-2004.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0709/cover-reservoir-doc-145millionDredgingStudy.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0711/cover-water-doc-225MillionDredging-final.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/news-water-doc-RWSABudget-fy2009.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0715/news-water-doc-adForRWSA.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0714/news-water-doc-FrederickDredgingResolutionResponse-dec2004.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0714/news-water-doc-AirportEmailandBriefing.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0714/news-water-doc-FrederickDredgingResolutionResponse-dec2004.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2001may-VHBSupplySummaryGamut.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2002july-CommunityWaterSupply.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2002oct-GForig798KContract.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2002oct-GForig798KContract.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2003Dec-GFdredgingPricyNuisances.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2004jan-GFworkReportCrestgateFails.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2004jan-GFscopeContractAmendment.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0716/news-water-doc2005june-GFdredgingFrontLoadHassles.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0717/news-water-doc-sierraClub.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0717/news-water-doc-GarysaysBuryUntilMay.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0718/news-water-doc-crutchfield.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0718/news-water-doc-thomas.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0718/news-water-doc-scaryDredgingPowerPoint.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0720/news-water-doc-CountyRateIncrease.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0720/news-water-doc-budgetProposed2008-09.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0720/news-water-doc-budgetProposed2008-09.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0721/news-water-doc-CitizensPlan.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0722/news-water-doc-VA-regsForPlans.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0722/news-water-doc-RWSA-MitigationPlan.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0722/news-water-doc-PermitSupportDocument-May2006.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0722/news-water-doc-LizPalmerPerspective.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0723/news-water-doc-letterByKendraHamilton.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/images/issues/2008/0723/news-water-doc-DraftResolution.rtf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/news-crutchfield-water-revisited.doc
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-damhalt-highlighted.doc
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-damhalt.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-oconnellsurprise.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-dredging-highlighted.doc
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-dredging-highlighted.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-70millionpressrelease.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/water-raggedmtndam-capitalbreakdown.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-harperconservationmemo.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-oconnell-whoisharper.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/11/news-water-graph-conservation10years.pdf
- http://readthehook.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/rwsa-big-dam-big-money.pdf
Please find the 2 young men,who appeared at a meeting, They said that they had in 2004 given an offer to do the dredging + disposal of the mud for $ 20m. Today they would ask $ 24 m because of the high diesel price. They should be interviewed seriously. The dredging is part of the long term solution and not a total 50 years program.